Booked & Scene

The Cher Show at North Shore Music Theatre takes audiences through the life and career of one of pop culture’s most iconic performers. Framed as a musical biography and directed by Kevin P. Hill Cher’s story is told through three versions of herself: Babe, Lady, and Star each representing a different era of her life. Together, they narrate the highs and lows of fame, love, reinvention, and resilience. With a catalog of hits that span decades, we pull back the curtain to see the life of the woman who has truly done it all and lived to sing about it.

Three Chers Are Better Than One

Sara Gettelfinger as Star is a knockout. From her first entrance to her final bow, she commands the stage with presence, and an uncanny Cher energy. Her vocals soar, her acting is layered, and her performance of “The Way of Love,” “Believe,” and “I Got You Babe (Reprise)” were major standouts. She moves effortlessly from humor to heartbreak anchoring the show with a legendary presence. It’s a demanding role, leading us through decades of Cher’s life, and Gettelfinger makes it look easy. You can feel how much fun she’s having, and that joy radiates into the audience.

Charissa Hogeland as Lady is the night’s revelation. She is magnetic from start to finish, blending perfect comedic timing and devastating lows in a way that feels entirely too real. “Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down)” was gut-wrenching, while “Ain’t Nobody’s Business” sparkled with wit and fun. Her duet with Gettelfinger on “Strong Enough” was both fierce and moving. Hogeland brings a full emotional range that makes her impossible to look away from.

Madeline Hudelson as Babe rounds out the trio. Her scenes with Angie Schworer’s Georgia Holt add warmth and humor, especially in “Da Doo Ron Ron.” Her chemistry with Frankie Marasa 5th as Sonny is charming, particularly in the early stages of their relationship.

The Company She Keeps

Several supporting performances help make this production shine. Angie Schworer gives a heartfelt turn as Georgia Holt and nails her comedic timing as Lucille Ball. Dan Fenaughty’s multiple roles including Bob Mackie, Robert Altman, and Frank are handled with finesse, and his voice is excellent in “Ain’t Nobody’s Business.” Alfie Parker Jr. as Bob Mackie’s Assistant adds just the right touch of humor every time he steps on stage, and Ben Broughton impresses with sharp delivery and well-differentiated characters as he portrays Phil Spector, Sid the Censor, Male ET Reporter.

Milena Comeau’s fierce turn as Dark Lady deserves special mention as her dancing was precise and electric. The entire female ensemble deserves a standing ovation of their own. Every number they’re in sparkles with energy and precision, proving once again how essential a strong ensemble is to a show like this.

All That Glitters

Sara Andreas’ choreography is one of this production’s brightest highlights. It’s bold, detailed, and distinct, showcasing the ensemble’s talent in every number. The iconic costumes, coordinated by Rebecca Glick, are another major win. From sequins to feathers, each look nods to Cher’s legendary style, and the cast handles a dizzying number of quick changes with ease.

Musical direction by Milton Granger also deserves praise. The pacing of the music felt tight and confident, keeping the show in sync throughout which is a noticeable improvement from some previous NSMT productions where the tempo sometimes wavered.

Gypsies, Tramps, and Missed Spots

The lighting design by Jack Mehler unfortunately misses the mark. Some of the strobing effects were overly intense, even distracting, and there were several moments when performers were left in dim light during key scenes. It pulled focus from what was otherwise a polished production.

At just over three hours, the show’s length is another challenge. The pacing feels strong through most of Act 1 and early Act 2, but it begins to drag near the end. Despite all that stage time, it’s hard to shake the feeling that we never fully get under the skin of who Cher is beyond her public persona. While longtime fans will find plenty to love, younger audiences may find it harder to connect unless they already have affection for her music.

An Icon Worth Applauding 

Overall, The Cher Show at North Shore Music Theatre is a vibrant, talent-filled night that celebrates one of entertainment’s most enduring icons. Sara Gettelfinger and Charissa Hogeland deliver powerhouse performances, supported by stellar choreography, costumes, and vocals across the board. Whether you grew up with Cher or only know a few of her hits, there’s something here that will make you smile, sing along (don’t worry you’re allowed to during the finale), and yes, believe in life after love. The Cher Show runs through November 2, 2025. 

📸: Paul Lyden